Bot Tester · Item

MNQ AI Trader

MNQ AI Trader · Execution/risk architecture + LLM decision layer (paper-trading system)

full botdebugging data blockedno reproduced evidence
Stage
debugging data blocked
Licence
review required
Blockers
2
Leakage audit
pending

Claims

What the upstream repository, author or a static read asserts — never evidence
unverified
Broker/local position reconciliation, hard safety gates, commission handling, DOM/order-flow features and paper-trading infrastructure.
claimed by upstream code reading (static audit)
unverified
Upstream explicitly describes it as paper trading, not live-money validated.
claimed by upstream documentation
This is a limitation disclosed upstream, not a performance claim.

Reproduced by TradeRep

Only findings with an openable evidence artifact count

Nothing reproduced yet, so no performance figure may be attributed to this item. Promotion requires independently reproduced evidence — a README claim is not a result.

Source & licence

Repository
meatham07-design/mnq-ai-trader
Upstream
fork of an external author's repository
Immutable SHA
Not pinned yet — reproduction should record one.
Licence status
review required — Execution/risk concepts may be reimplemented clean-room; direct reuse requires license review.
Disposition
Mine execution/risk safeguards and benchmark its decision layer; do not treat as proven alpha.
Notes
Strongest current value is execution/risk architecture rather than demonstrated alpha (EXTERNAL_BOT_AUDIT_2026-09-17.md).

Audit targets, data & blockers

Audit targets
  • · prefilter vs LLM incremental value
  • · prompt/model drift
  • · DOM data dependence
  • · IBKR-specific execution assumptions
  • · paper/live fill gap
Test data
No recorded native sessions; DOM/order-flow features require tick/trade source data that OHLC cannot supply.
Blockers
  • mnq-ai-trader-no-recorded-sessions: No native recorded sessions exist, so deterministic historical replay feasibility is unresolved (DATA_BLOCKED).
    docs/status/TRADE_REP_MASTER_TRACKER.json
  • mnq-ai-trader-llm-cost-control: Historical audit must run with cached/offline LLM mode first to prevent uncontrolled API cost and nondeterministic re-evaluation.
    docs/EXTERNAL_FUTURES_BOT_VALIDATION_PLAN.md

Statistics

Baseline · stress · OOS · funded simulation
baseline
No recorded statistics.
stress
No recorded statistics.
oos
No recorded statistics.
funded simulation
No recorded statistics.

Reuse decisions

What is worth keeping, and what was rejected
Reusable pieces
  • · broker/local reconciliation
  • · hard safety gates
  • · commission handling
  • · DOM/order-flow feature extraction
Rejected pieces
None recorded.
Gate outcomes
No scientific gate has produced an outcome for this item.
Components extracted
Deterministic replay invariantsMarket-intelligence causality guards (order flow, volume profile, regime)

Read from research-output/registry/bot-testers.json · docs/status/TRADE_REP_MASTER_TRACKER.json